The Halloween Rulebuster
Hear Robert read this essay.8 min 54

Rulebuster
There comes a time in the career of every parent when we pause and reflect on whether or not we’re doing a good job at raising our kids. This happens, on average, about every 90 minutes or so.
Before having children, couples love to sit down and talk about consistency and manners and rules and such. And then you have your kid and reality smacks you in the side of the head like an errant slapshot. You find that life is more like, well, using your frequent flier miles. I know, I know, it’s a stretch, but stick with me here.
When you fly, most of the time, you only need, let’s say 25,000 miles for a ticket to somewhere in the continental U.S. But the airlines have this little trick they play: actually using those 25,000 to take a trip at a date and time that is remotely convenient for you is about as simple as breaking the 4 minute mile. In their limitless generosity, though, some airlines have come up with a scheme that they call “rulebuster.” The rulebuster is this: pay another 25,000 miles (that’s double, by the way) and you travel when you want.
So it is when raising children. Parents quickly find that there are rules and there are rules and sometimes you need to apply those extra 25,000 miles just to get on your way. Now kids have a near phenomenal ability to know when you are having one of those days and are primed to spend those extra miles. When it comes to loopholes, kids are like Wall Street accountants and can spot them a mile away.
We’ve found that in terms of consistent kid-raising, one of the most vexing subjects, especially to over-read, post-modern granola-crunchers like my wife and me, is probably food. I mean, nutrition is a big deal, right? We want our kids to grow strong and healthy and develop good eating habits, right? So, questions constantly come up: Hot or cold lunch? Organic or regular? Whole grain? Processed? High-glycemic or low? How much meat, dairy, soy, fruits, vegetables. Do potatoes count? Vitamins? Is pop allowed? McDonald’s? Do we really make them stay until their plates are cleaned? How many bites of green stuff before dessert? And sugar—oh, sugar. How much of that? Because, let’s be honest, who wouldn’t have chocolate for breakfast, lunch and dinner if we could. My kids sure would.
I mean, they have a sweet tooth the size of Mount Rushmore. At their current ages, which is 7, 4 and 2, they would cross a river of hot lava for a cherry sucker. They say a toddler, when he sees a gesture or some type of action, will remember it for eight months afterwards. I’ll bet, if there’s candy involved, it’s measured in years. When we go on errands and some nice shopkeeper or business owner hands them out a piece of candy, they will remember that person, what they were wearing, the weather that day, the store and the directions to the store with a memory that borders on the supernatural. “Can we go to the bank and get a sucker?” they say. “There’s the popcorn place!” “Hey Dad, that’s the gumball lady!” My toddler, by the way, once said the word “popcorn” 216 times in a row. But I digress…
The Nag Factor
Researchers in California have shown that, the more time children spend in front of the television or a video game, the more requests they make for treats. They’ve also shown that children are willing to ask for something they want on average 462,000 times, or something like that in order to get it. My response is: I hope they didn’t spend too many tax dollars to figure this one out.
Economists refer to the begging thing as the Nag Factor and marketers of goodies and toys have known this for years. Now, we don’t have TV in our house, so no nag factor, right? Wrong! There must be an evolutionary tendency for kids to beg from their parents—just watch the baby birds follow their mothers around your yard throughout the summer, still asking for food when they’re perfectly capable of getting it themselves. Maybe back in the old days, the cavekids who yelled the loudest got the extra piece of sabertooth steak and grew up to be strong and make more little cavebabies. I don’t know.
All I know is that begging for stuff is what kids do and sometimes we give in and sometimes we don’t. If your kids are not like this and you have one of those families that can leave a jar of candy on the counter long enough for the candy to actually go stale, all I can say is I hate you and I hope your children join a motorcycle gang and get married in a drive-through chapel in Vegas.
Free Candy!
Now, it’s not like my kids eat candy that often and I can count on one hand the times I’ve acquiesced to the inevitable question next to the gumball machine.
Enter Halloween. Now, if I sat down and tried to, I couldn’t come up with a cooler thing for a kid to do: dress up and go get FREE CANDY? It does not get any better than that—ever. Are you getting this? FREE CANDY!?
So, try to picture my kids this Halloween. We’d already been to four parties by the time it came to trick or treat, so their sugar highs were just kickin’ in. It was cold, but like I’ve said, it would have to be colder than, say, Pluto for them to think twice about trick or treating. My two boys were like a blur. Zoom! One house. Vroom! Two houses. Three, four, five. Our little girl was cold and I had to carry her, but she didn’t complain once. I put her down in front of each door and she happily walked away with more loot. Our kids didn’t even look at what they were getting or how full their bags were. It was the principle of the thing! Free Candy!!!
After a couple of blocks, they had a few good handfuls of goodies and we went to the last party before heading home. Now comes the parenting part: what to do with all the loot? If I left it up to my wife, she would have given them each a couple of pieces, then thrown the rest away when they weren’t looking. My wife, bless her, comes from a family of naturally nervous people and I think she’s afraid that the kids are going to drop dead if they don’t get their greens at every meal. I have her on video actually chasing our first child around the house with a bowl in one hand and a spoon in the other trying to BRIBE him to take one last bite of whatever it was. Bribing is a whole other ball of wax—sometimes it’s good, sometimes not.
A Rulebuster Time of Year
Me, I think Halloween is a rulebuster time of year. I prefer to let them dive right in and get it over with so I don’t have to hear any begging for the next week. So, the next morning, at the first Nag Effect, conveniently after my wife left for work, I gave both my younger kids their whole baskets and told them to have at it. They just stared at me. No, really. Eat it all—it’s fine. I went into my study to check my email.
Five minutes went by. Then ten. Fifteen. At twenty, I peeked around the corner to see them making virtual love to their candy baskets. They were gazing at their uneaten candy in such a state of bliss, I dared not interrupt. Charlotte had unwrapped every piece from her bag and spread them all out in front of her. Louis was throwing it in his mouth so fast that his top and bottom lip couldn’t make contact. I flashed back to a scene of their older brother a year beforehand. We had spilt some hot chocolate and I found him actually lying on the counter LICKING it all up, his eyes closed, his hands grasping the formica. I felt like a peeping Tom and slunk back to the study.
We Always Do
So, after three meals of Hershey’s Kisses, gumballs, suckers and a couple of sore tummies, the Halloween bags were reduced to wrappers and a few pencils and pennies. After the sugar crash, the meltdowns, lots of furious teeth brushing and bedtime, we cleaned the countertops and crawled into bed. Another rulebuster and the kids didn’t drop dead, the world didn’t come to an end and our family values were more or less intact.
This year’s candy orgy that is Halloween was over and we all survived to see another one. But what’s that I hear? Christmas music in the stores?! Time to start saving up—only five weeks to get back up to 50,000 miles. We’ll make it. We always do.
Shades of a Warrior
Return of the Manitous